Coach Carole Ramblings

Celtic, Mythical and More …

What do I know about reflective practice?

6 Comments

My research shows me that there are four elements about reflection and four types of reflective practice that I could choose from:

Descriptive: – no discussion beyond description with no evidence of reflection

Descriptive reflective: – description of events with some evidence of deeper consideration in relatively descriptive language.  No real evidence of alternative viewpoints.

Dialogic reflection: – There is a ‘stepping back’ from the events and actions which leads to different levels of discussion.  A sense of ‘mulling over’ events is shown.  Evaluation of judgements and a consideration of possible alternatives for explaining and hypothesising about them is shown.  The reflection is analytical or integrative, linking factors and perspectives.

Critical Reflection: – aware that actions and events may be ‘located’ within and explicable by multiple perspectives, but are located in and influenced by multiple socio-political contexts.

 

My reflections today are about the way in which the ‘reason for reflecting’ and the selected reflection tools themselves influence the type of reflections being used. Let me unpack my ‘reasons for reflecting’ in this blog and then look at the differences that have occurred in the nature of the reflections that I have posted over a period of time. I first began blogging in 2002 during my year as a Flexible Learning Leader – you’ll notice only one post in that year. I was testing the waters between 2004 and 2006 with a greater attention to blog posts, but interestingly no blogs in 2003, only one in 2004 and two in 2005. This was me reflecting on my work – but just for me – no desire for alternative viewpoints. Another interesting suite of posts (11 to be exact) happened in February 2009 and I was intrigued to go find out what was happening in my life then. A new grandchild – worthy of a post; and several postings from an Eportfolio Symposium – the point at which my eportfolio dreamtime began.

Early years of blogging reveal a descriptive reflective style and the latter years a dialogic reflective style. In the latter years I enlisted the aid of the Comments in WordPress to invite the opinions of others. And in 2010 utilised the commentary to add to my dialogic reflective practice. It has only been in the latter years where I have become more interested in creating and maintaining an eportfolio and the various tools I have learned to use for that purpose have changed the way in which I think about the: the types of artefacts I wish to include and display as well as the types of reflective practice that I include about them in the eportfolio. Much of my learning about the pedagogy of eportfolios has been from Dr Helen Barrett and I recently followed her lead and prepared yet another eportfolio for myself in a Google site. This process has helped me in the task of advising others about their eportfolios – the type of reflections they do – and the type of tool they choose.

In September I facilitated an online event in Elluminate about Reflective Practice for the Eportfolio Community of Practice (EpCoP) and engaged with the audience about their methods of reflective practice.

In October I will facilitate another online event in Elluminate about the Functionalities of Eportfolios and will begin a Voicethread and ask members of the EpCoP to contribute to it. The Voicethread activity will be my final presentation for the Facilitating Online program and will be one of the deliverables for that project in my capacity as Facilitator. So you could say ‘two birds with one stone’ – a smart approach to reflective practice – and hopefully a move towards Critical Reflection.

Advertisements

Author: coachcarole

Coach Carole is the name by which many of you will know me - in my role as coach and mentor for teachers, project teams and networks facilitators. I work independently as an elearning consultant for my business Macro Dimensions.

6 thoughts on “What do I know about reflective practice?

  1. Hi, Carole,

    Yes, I too learnt a lot from Helen, particularly by considering or reflecting upon her list of metaphors. However, I think that reflection is not only ‘introspection’ or reflecting by one’s self. It is an invigorating experience to consider the opinions of others. – Either because they supplement your thinking or because in disagreeing with their opinions it strengthens your own convictions.

    Secondly, I see reflection or evaluation as being an often formal and constructive process of considering the five aspects of evaluation as I attempt to describe in my blog: http://efoliointheuk.blogspot.com/2009/07/what-is-reflection.html

    Best Wishes,
    Ray T

  2. Hi Carol, thanks for sharing your critical reflections on your own practice and the framework you are using to do this. You also demonstrated critical reflection in your response to my questions at http://markspain.wordpress.com/2010/10/05/ideas-for-mini-conference/#comment-56. I value your contributions.

  3. Hi Ray, I appreciate your critical reflection here – I enjoy being able to consider the opinion of others – and it seems like it is easy done in a blog with comments. The task of reflection is close to that of evaluation – I like the five P’s of your Evaluation: Product, Process, Person, Problems and Potential – and will now consider how to weave that into my advice I give to others about their reflective practices. The five P’s would provide a great framework for a set of appreciative inquiry questions that one might use for reflecting on your own learning. Thanks Ray, you’re wisdom is taking me to a new level of undertanding. CC

  4. Hi Mark, Thanks for dropping by – its useful to receive the opinions of others about the impact of comments elsewhere – I’m beginning to think more deeply about the type of tools that enable the ‘outside in’ reflection. So that leads me to the functionality of an e-portfolio system or tool – and how to improve the ability for others to comment, reflect or challenge. I’m off now to explore how best to do that in Mahara and Googlesites. CC

  5. It is certainly interesting for me to read this article. Thank you for it. I like such themes and everything connected to them. I would like to read a bit more soon.

    Jane Watcerson
    las vegas escort independent

  6. Hi Carole
    Gaining this new knowledge regarding the different levels of reflection and the benefits of reflections are making me realize what a solitary and insular person I am. I have not thought much previously about using reflection and feedback as tools to improve understanding and performance.
    Thanks for you blog, especially this blog post.